The Colorful Story of Blue Shropshire Cheese: A Slice of Culinary History
JANUARY 02, 2026
Discovering the Alluring Mystery of Blue Shropshire Cheese
When you're out perusing the artisanal cheeses at Murray's Cheese in Pagosa Springs, you might stumble upon a vibrant surprise known as Blue Shropshire. This cheese isn't just a feast for the eyes; it's a rich tapestry of history, craft, and flavor that interweaves the narratives of British culture, agriculture, and innovation.
The Art of a Colorful Cheese
First encountered on a cheeseboard, Blue Shropshire captivates with its striking orange hue laced with blue veins. But why such a curious color? The bright orange, attributed to a natural dye called annatto, gives it a cheerful appearance that invites the curious tasters among you to indulge!
While one might hastily compare it to Stilton, Blue Shropshire stands as its own unique creation, shrouded in a bit of legend and perplexity. Some may consider it a mere marketing trick, but this cheese offers a sensory experience that transcends mere aesthetics. The infusion of annatto not only enhances its visual appeal but also plays a nuanced role in its texture and flavor. This coloring has roots reaching back to 17th-century practices where dairymen mixed dyes into their cheese to enhance the perceived quality of seasonal variations.
A Migraine of Misunderstood History
Interestingly, Blue Shropshire was not born in Shropshire, nor does it strictly follow in the culinary footsteps of its cousins. Instead, this cheese originated in the Scottish Highlands in the 1970s, resulting from a collaboration involving cheesemaker Andy Williamson who combined Scottish milk with a Stilton recipe using annatto, which cleverly aligned its branding with the idyllic imagery of Shropshire.
And just when you think you've grasped its origin story, there appears the counter-narrative led by Dennis Biggins, a cheese merchant from Shropshire in the 1930s who may have also contributed to its early forms. The saga of Blue Shropshire is an intricate tale of migration, reinvention, and the constant tussle between tradition and modernity, showcasing a cheese that is truly a 'displaced' culinary gem.
The Cooperative Spirit: Long Clawson Dairy
However, the story of Blue Shropshire reaches its depth through Long Clawson Dairy, a cooperative founded in 1911 by a band of farmers fighting against dominating middlemen in agriculture. Their founding in a pub called The Royal Oak is symbolically significant; pubs represent community and democracy, critical aspects woven into the cooperative’s DNA.
The cooperative consists of 43 farms located in Leicestershire, Nottinghamshire, and Derbyshire, all working together to produce this beloved cheese. The commitment to quality radiates through this localized approach, as member farmers are incentivized to ensure the milk is premium quality, directly tying it to the delicious cheese produced.
Why the Unique Flavor?
One of the secrets behind the smooth, creamy texture of Blue Shropshire is the specialty of its production method. Rather than using the typical high-speed pumps common in industrial cheesemaking, Long Clawson employs a gravity-fed process. The curds are gently moved between vessels by gravity, maintaining their integrity throughout production, ensuring you receive a delightful mouthfeel.
This care translates into flavor too: the cheese is often aged longer than its Stilton counterparts—about 12 weeks—allowing for a flavor profile that deepens and mellows as time passes. This makes Blue Shropshire an inviting introduction to blue cheeses for those who might find the sharpness of Stilton a little intimidating.
Pairing Possibilities
So when should you dive into a wedge of Blue Shropshire? Traditionally, it finds its finest companion in a rich fruitcake, a pairing celebrated in Yorkshire. Imagine dense, sweet cake brushed with the saltiness of the cheese; it’s a culinary tradition that marries the creamy and savory with the sweet, creating a whole new dimension of taste.
If you’re looking to impress at your next dinner party, experiment with this pairing, and alongside a crisp glass of port or a spiced ale, you’ll unlock a magnificent flavor-harmony.
Not Just a Cheese
Blue Shropshire is undoubtedly a cheese worth celebrating, symbolizing resilience, community, and the beautiful intertwining of history and flavor. Whether you’re visiting or living in Pagosa Springs, become a part of the story—explore the rich, orange, and blue hues of Blue Shropshire the next time you’re at Murray’s Cheese. It’s more than a slice of cheese; it’s a bite of history!
Embrace the Cheese Journey
Next time you reach for a cheese that evokes intrigue, down to its very color, Blue Shropshire is an exquisite option. The marriage of complex backgrounds, cooperative craftsmanship, and flavor innovation ensures that your palate will be treated to a unique adventure—one that aligns with a rich tradition while embracing modern culinary creativity. Don’t forget to educate your dinner companions; melted cheese legend awaits!
More in